2012 Fantasy Baseball, Week 15: Is James Shields A Good Buy Low Option?
James Shields
After a magnificent 2011 that saw James Shields transform from innings eater to a bona fide ace, this year’s version leaves much to be desired. With the first half over, owners are being burnt by Shields to the tune of a 4.17 ERA and 1.42 WHIP. While regression was an obvious call when his name was up to be drafted, the results are so far off from the price paid. His ADP, per MockDraftCentral, was 67.1. This pushes him near 5-6 round territory and damn close to being your staff’s number 1 guy. So, why leave hope for a guy sitting in the 4s? The answer is simply, bad luck.
The real “Big Games James” is a cross between his amazing 2011 and his subpar 2012. He won’t repeat the 2.82 ERA and 1.04 WHIP of last year, but he will provide a boost to savvy owners who keep or buy-low. Considering that his only season below a 3.5 ERA was last year, it was expectant that a repeat wouldn’t surface. By tempering expectations, owners should be able to stomach the final line. While, the end of the season will not represent the improvements that are incoming, Shields can be the difference between hoisting the .jpeg trophy and waiting for next season.
This year’s version of Shields isn’t too far off from the guy who was third-place in CY voting. His K-rate is steady at 8.27 K/9. It’s above league average and on-par with his career numbers. His walks are not an issue, either. The 2.58 BB% is close to normal ratios and cannot be the culprit behind the high WHIP or even the high ERA. He isn’t even allowing more HRs or stranding less runners – James Shields is just having some really bad luck.
The one statistic that stands out is his glaring BABIP. The batted balls in play are routinely becoming hits instead of outs, and therefore his rate of .335 is above league and career averages. If the percentage normalizes and outs are actually recorded instead of hits, Shields should see an automatic change in ERA and WHIP. Since walks and Ks are not the problem, the investment will pay off. Already, his xFIP stands at a healthy 3.44 – which is more in-line with the numbers expected of a fantasy ace.
The lone factor in the lack of change for Shields is his pitch changes. A sudden decrease in efficiency for all his pitches is changing the percentages of throwing frequency. He’s throwing the fastball less and increasing the amount of cutters and change-ups. As a result, his fastball efficiency dropped to -8.7, the cutter is -4.7, and the curveball is -1.1. Even his best pitch, the change-up dropped to 4.4 after an amazing 17.7 efficiency rating last year. The repertoire needs to be fixed and normalized for the complete turn-around and only the Rays’ staff (and Shields) can do it.
While a change is coming, it is not guaranteed. The bad luck may go away and if it does, the investment for Shields will pay off in a great way. He already boosts a strong K-rate and low BBs, add in the normalized ERA and WHIP and a staff anchor is what you get.
The real “Big Games James” is a cross between his amazing 2011 and his subpar 2012. He won’t repeat the 2.82 ERA and 1.04 WHIP of last year, but he will provide a boost to savvy owners who keep or buy-low. Considering that his only season below a 3.5 ERA was last year, it was expectant that a repeat wouldn’t surface. By tempering expectations, owners should be able to stomach the final line. While, the end of the season will not represent the improvements that are incoming, Shields can be the difference between hoisting the .jpeg trophy and waiting for next season.
This year’s version of Shields isn’t too far off from the guy who was third-place in CY voting. His K-rate is steady at 8.27 K/9. It’s above league average and on-par with his career numbers. His walks are not an issue, either. The 2.58 BB% is close to normal ratios and cannot be the culprit behind the high WHIP or even the high ERA. He isn’t even allowing more HRs or stranding less runners – James Shields is just having some really bad luck.
The one statistic that stands out is his glaring BABIP. The batted balls in play are routinely becoming hits instead of outs, and therefore his rate of .335 is above league and career averages. If the percentage normalizes and outs are actually recorded instead of hits, Shields should see an automatic change in ERA and WHIP. Since walks and Ks are not the problem, the investment will pay off. Already, his xFIP stands at a healthy 3.44 – which is more in-line with the numbers expected of a fantasy ace.
The lone factor in the lack of change for Shields is his pitch changes. A sudden decrease in efficiency for all his pitches is changing the percentages of throwing frequency. He’s throwing the fastball less and increasing the amount of cutters and change-ups. As a result, his fastball efficiency dropped to -8.7, the cutter is -4.7, and the curveball is -1.1. Even his best pitch, the change-up dropped to 4.4 after an amazing 17.7 efficiency rating last year. The repertoire needs to be fixed and normalized for the complete turn-around and only the Rays’ staff (and Shields) can do it.
While a change is coming, it is not guaranteed. The bad luck may go away and if it does, the investment for Shields will pay off in a great way. He already boosts a strong K-rate and low BBs, add in the normalized ERA and WHIP and a staff anchor is what you get.
Written by Tim Lee exclusively for TheFantasyFix.com. Follow Tim on Twitter at @SHBL_Tim.
Follow The Fantasy Fix on Twitter @thefantasyfix
or for Free Fantasy Sports Advice use our Quick Fix to get help with your team!
The Author
